With AI (Artificial Intelligence) and LLMs (Large Language Models) now providing instant access to solutions in Physics and Mathematics, it raises the question: are human mentors still important?  The answer is resoundingly yes! And hopefully this article will convince the reader why this is the case.

Unlike AI language models, which often parrot information without truly grasping the nuances, human mentors can diagnose the specific reasons a student might struggle with complex topics. A human mentor can personally relate to the conceptual challenges a student might be facing, drawing upon his/her past experiences while learning the subject as a student themselves. This allows them to explain intricate details to the student, which a generic AI response would fail to reflect.

In addition, AI lacks any real-world context, whereas experienced mentors can draw from their own extensive academic and industry backgrounds to make abstract ideas come alive through practical examples. They can make the complex lessons fun and interactive. Also working with a mentor motivates a student to develop good study habits which can be applied to multiple subjects.

LLMs may solve problems, but they fall short in cultivating the critical thinking necessary for scientific inquiry; they cannot teach learners how to design experiments or debug a flawed hypothesis. AI also often provides incorrect answers or an incomplete methodology.

Thus, while preparing for hyper competitive exams and navigating intense college applications, the role of a human mentor in explaining conceptual details, clarifying doubts and counselling/motivating students is unmatched. AI and LLM can supplement the educational ecosystem, but can never replace human mentors, as we witness further evolution in pedagogy.

If you or someone you know would benefit from our services, do contact us https://vectorideas.com/contact-us/ with any questions in this regard for enrolment.

© Dr. Arijita Mukherjee Chakraborty, PhD. Physics, Co-founder, Faculty and Mentor at Vector Educational and Consultancy Services